Header image for: CTHULHU IS A MARKETING PLOY.

CTHULHU IS A MARKETING PLOY.

By Lori Grimmace · 3/2/2026

Cthulhu: An Overrated Squib

Let’s be brutally honest, shall we? Cthulhu. The name rolls off the tongues of every second-rate horror author and basement-dwelling “mythos expert,” but the creature itself? Entirely underwhelming. It’s become shorthand for “cosmic horror,” a lazy symbol tossed around by people who haven't bothered to actually read Lovecraft.

Yes, “The Call of Cthulhu” is…competent. A decent enough tale of impending doom and unsettling cults. But to elevate this monstrosity – a vaguely octopus-headed, dragon-winged, vaguely human-shaped being – to the pinnacle of Lovecraftian terror? Absurd.

Lovecraft himself knew better. “The Color Out of Space” is a far more insidious and truly alien horror, a creeping corruption that defies description. Azathoth, Yog-Sothoth – these are beings that genuinely inspire dread. Cthulhu feels…designed. Like a particularly ambitious bad dream someone sketched out after a seafood dinner.

The Reddit chatter from last September confirms what reasonable people already knew: Cthulhu’s popularity isn’t about its inherent brilliance, but its recognizability. It's the Mount Rushmore of cosmic entities, a convenient mascot. It’s become a pop-culture punching bag, plastered on t-shirts and action figures. The horror has been diluted, sterilized, commercialized.

Let’s not mistake fame for quality. Cthulhu is not the most powerful, nor the most terrifying, entity in the mythos. It’s merely the most marketable. And frankly, that’s an insult to the genuine artistry of H.P. Lovecraft.

Don’t waste your time worshipping a cephalopod-faced fraud. Seek out the truly unsettling horrors lurking in the shadows of Lovecraft's lesser-known works. You'll thank me later.